Amazon.com, Inc. - Key Themes Briefing (2012-2013)
Sources: Amazon Inc. – 2012 Proxy Statement
Amazon Inc. - 2012 Letters to Shareholders
Amazon Inc. - 2012 Annual Report
I. Executive Summary
This briefing synthesizes key themes and facts from Amazon's 2012 Annual Report and 2012 Proxy Statement. The documents highlight Amazon's unwavering commitment to customer obsession and long-term shareholder value creation, even at the expense of short-term profitability. Proactive innovation, strategic investments in new and existing ventures (e.g., Prime, AWS, Kindle), and a lean, cost-conscious culture underpin this strategy. The company acknowledges and actively manages various risks associated with its rapid expansion and global operations.
II. Core Business Philosophy and Strategy
Amazon's strategic approach is fundamentally defined by its customer-centric culture and long-term thinking, as articulated by CEO Jeffrey P. Bezos in his letter to shareholders: "Our energy at Amazon comes from the desire to impress customers rather than the zeal to best competitors." This philosophy, established in the original 1997 letter, remains a "defining element of our culture."
A. Customer Obsession and Proactivity
Internal Drive to Improve: Amazon is "internally driven to improve our services, adding benefits and features, before we have to. We lower prices and increase value for customers before we have to. We invent before we have to." This proactive approach is a "somewhat subtle one" but earns customer trust and drives rapid improvements.
Surprise and Delight: The company actively seeks opportunities to exceed customer expectations, leading to "Wow" moments.
Proactive Refunds: Automated systems identify and refund customers for poor experiences, like video playback issues. An industry observer was "surprised by the proactive refund" for poor video playback, writing: "Wow…Talk about putting customers first."
Pre-order Price Protection: Amazon guarantees the lowest price between order time and release date, proactively refunding customers without requiring them to monitor prices. This "surprises, delights, and earns trust."
Author Royalties: Amazon Publishing shifted to monthly royalty payments for authors, "sixty days in arrears," contrasting with the industry standard of twice a year, addressing a "major dissatisfier" for authors as customers.
Value-Driven Offerings:Amazon Prime: Selection grew "more than 15 million items in Prime, up 15x since we launched in 2005," with Prime Instant Video selection tripling to "more than 38,000 movies and TV episodes." The Kindle Owners’ Lending Library also "more than tripled to over 300,000 books," including the Harry Potter series. These were proactive improvements, not forced by competition.
Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA): This "game changer for our seller customers" allows third-party sellers to use Amazon's fulfillment network, making their items eligible for Prime benefits and boosting their sales, while also expanding Prime selection for consumers.
Kindle Devices: The strategy is to "sell premium hardware at roughly breakeven prices. We want to make money when people use our devices – not when people buy our devices." This approach aligns with customers, allowing them to use older devices without pressure to upgrade.
Amazon Web Services (AWS): A prime example of internal motivation. In 2012, AWS launched "159 new features and services" and "reduced AWS prices 27 times since launching 7 years ago." AWS Trusted Advisor actively informs customers "they’re paying us more than they need to," saving them "millions of dollars." This innovation pace is driven by the desire to get customers to "say ‘Wow’" even as AWS is the "widely recognized leader in its area."
B. Long-Term Shareholder Value Creation
Alignment of Interests: Bezos explicitly states, "Take a long-term view, and the interests of customers and shareholders align." Proactively delighting customers "earns trust, which earns more business from those customers, even in new business arenas."
Investment Philosophy: Amazon prioritizes "long-term market leadership considerations rather than short-term profitability considerations or short-term Wall Street reactions."
Growth over Short-Term Profitability: The company will "balance our focus on growth with emphasis on long-term profitability and capital management. At this stage, we choose to prioritize growth because we believe that scale is central to achieving the potential of our business model." (1997 letter)
Benjamin Graham Quote: Bezos frequently quotes Benjamin Graham: “In the short run, the market is a voting machine but in the long run, it is a weighing machine.” Amazon aims to "build a heavier company" by focusing on excellent customer experience rather than short-term stock price fluctuations.
Bold Investment Decisions: The company will "make bold rather than timid investment decisions where we see a sufficient probability of gaining market leadership advantages. Some of these investments will pay off, others will not, and we will have learned another valuable lesson in either case." (1997 letter)
Lean Culture and Efficiency: Amazon works "hard to spend wisely and maintain our lean culture," especially given periods of net losses. This includes efforts to reduce variable costs per unit (e.g., direct sourcing, supplier discounts, defect reduction) and leverage fixed costs (e.g., process efficiencies, technology infrastructure, website enhancements).
III. Operational and Financial Highlights (2010-2012)
A. Revenue Growth and Segments
Overall Growth: Total net sales increased significantly: 27% in 2012, 41% in 2011, and 40% in 2010.
Segment Performance:North America: Sales grew by 30% in 2012, 43% in 2011, and 46% in 2010. Growth was driven by increased unit sales, price reductions, growth in electronics and general merchandise, improved in-stock availability, and increased selection.
International: Sales grew by 23% in 2012, 38% in 2011, and 33% in 2010. Similar drivers to North America, but impacted by foreign exchange rates. Amazon expects its International segment to "represent 50% or more of our consolidated net sales" over time.
Sales Mix Shift: There's a notable shift towards "Electronics and other general merchandise," which increased from 54% of consolidated net sales in 2010 to 63% in 2012, while "Media" sales decreased from 43% to 33%. "Other" (non-retail activities like AWS, advertising, co-branded credit cards) remained around 3-4%.
B. Investments and Expenses
Heavy Investments: Despite a perception of being "too generous, shareholder indifferent, or even at odds with being a for-profit company," Amazon emphasizes heavy investments in "Prime, AWS, Kindle, digital media, and customer experience in general."
Fulfillment Costs: Increased due to higher sales volume, inventory levels, sales mix shifts, and expansion of fulfillment capacity. Net shipping cost increased from $(1,386) million in 2010 to $(2,854) million in 2012, reflecting customer adoption of shipping offers, product mix shifts, and more expensive shipping methods.
Technology and Content Costs: Increased significantly (57% growth in 2012) due to payroll and related expenses for digital initiatives, and increased spending on technology infrastructure, including AWS. These costs are expected to "increase over time."
Capitalized costs for internal-use software and website development grew from $213 million in 2010 to $454 million in 2012.
Capital Expenditures: Increased dramatically from $979 million in 2010 to $3,785 million in 2012, primarily due to "additional investments in support of continued business growth due to investments in technology infrastructure, including AWS, and additional capacity to support our fulfillment operations." In 2012, this included a $1.4 billion acquisition of corporate office space and land in Seattle.
C. Profitability and Cash Flow
Operating Income Volatility: Income from operations decreased by 22% in 2012 and 39% in 2011, after a 25% increase in 2010. This volatility is a consequence of significant investments.
Net Income (Loss): Amazon reported a net loss of $(39) million in 2012, compared to net income of $631 million in 2011 and $1,152 million in 2010.
Free Cash Flow: Decreased from $2,516 million in 2010 to $395 million in 2012, "primarily due to increased capital expenditures partially offset by higher operating cash flows." Amazon focuses on "long-term, sustainable growth in free cash flow per share."
Operating Cycle: The company maintains a "cash-generating operating cycle" with high inventory velocity, meaning it "generally collect[s] from consumers before our payments to suppliers come due." Inventory turnover was 9 in 2012, 10 in 2011, and 11 in 2010.
Income Taxes: Effective tax rates vary due to earnings in lower tax rate jurisdictions (e.g., Luxembourg) and losses in foreign jurisdictions without tax benefits. The 2012 effective tax rate was "higher than both the 35% U.S. federal statutory rate and our effective tax rates in 2011 and 2010" due to lower pre-tax income and other factors.
IV. Risks and Challenges
Amazon operates in a "rapidly evolving and intensely competitive" environment and faces numerous risks:
Competition: Intense competition from "physical-world retailers, publishers, vendors, distributors, manufacturers, and producers," as well as "other online e-commerce and mobile e-commerce sites." Many competitors "have greater resources, longer histories, more customers, and greater brand recognition."
Expansion Strain: Rapid global expansion places "significant strain on our management, personnel, operations, systems, technical performance, financial resources, and internal financial control and reporting functions."
New Offerings: Expansion into new products, services, technologies, and geographies carries "additional business, legal, financial and competitive risks," with potential for lower profitability and service disruptions.
Operating Result Fluctuations: Sales and operating results "fluctuate for many other reasons," including customer retention, seller network expansion, product terms, competitive actions, and economic conditions.
International Operations: Costly to establish and maintain, with risks from "local economic and political conditions," government regulation, foreign ownership restrictions, and currency fluctuations.
Fulfillment Optimization: Failure to "adequately predict customer demand or otherwise optimize and operate our fulfillment centers successfully" can lead to increased costs or harm the business. Reliance on limited shipping companies and potential for disruptions from external factors (weather, labor disputes) are also risks.
Seasonality: A disproportionate amount of sales occurs in the fourth quarter, straining operations and potentially leading to inventory issues or system interruptions.
Acquisitions and Investments: Integration difficulties, loss of key personnel, and potential impairment of assets are risks.
Foreign Exchange Risk: Significant exposure to foreign exchange rate fluctuations, which can materially impact reported results.
Key Personnel Reliance: Dependence on senior management, "particularly Jeffrey P. Bezos," with no "key person" life insurance.
Data Security: Risk of data loss or security breaches, which could "expose us or our customers to a risk of loss or misuse of such information, adversely affect our operating results, result in litigation or potential liability."
System Interruption: Occasional system interruptions and delays could reduce sales and attractiveness of services.
Inventory Risk: Exposed to "significant inventory risks that may adversely affect our operating results as a result of seasonality, new product launches, rapid changes in product cycles and pricing, defective merchandise, changes in consumer demand."
Intellectual Property: Risk of not adequately protecting IP rights or being accused of infringing third-party rights.
Volatile Stock Price: The trading price of common stock "fluctuates significantly" due to various factors.
Government Regulation: Evolving regulations on the Internet, e-commerce, and electronic devices "may impede our growth."
Sales/Consumption Taxes: Risk of "substantial tax liabilities, including for past sales, as well as penalties and interest" from jurisdictions attempting to impose collection obligations.
Supplier Relationships: Lack of long-term arrangements with most suppliers could lead to availability issues or increased costs.
Payments-Related Risks: Subject to fees, compliance requirements, fraud, and reliance on third-party processors.
Fraudulent Seller Activities: Potential liability for "fraudulent or unlawful activities of sellers" on its platform.
V. Corporate Governance
Board Leadership: Jeff Bezos serves as Chairman and CEO. The Board believes this structure is appropriate given his founding role and ownership stake. An independent lead director (currently Mr. Alberg) presides over executive sessions of independent directors and provides agenda direction.
Director Independence: The majority of the Board consists of independent directors. The Board assesses independence based on Nasdaq rules and takes into account various relationships and transactions.
Risk Oversight: The full Board has overall responsibility, delegating specific risk management oversight to the Audit Committee (financial reporting, independent auditors, internal audit, legal/regulatory compliance) and the Leadership Development and Compensation Committee (succession planning, executive compensation, equity plans).
Committees: The Board has an Audit Committee, Leadership Development and Compensation Committee, and Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee, all comprised entirely of independent directors.
Director Nominations: The Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee seeks candidates with "diversity of experience and perspectives" and evaluates qualifications such as commitment to long-term shareholder interests, customer experience skills, internet savvy, leadership ability, and ethics.
Director Compensation: Directors do not receive cash compensation but are eligible for stock-based awards (restricted stock units) vesting over several years. Jeff Bezos, due to his substantial ownership, "has never received any stock-based compensation from Amazon.com."
Executive Compensation: Primarily stock-based compensation to tie it to "long-term shareholder value." Base salaries are "significantly less than those paid by similarly situated companies." No nonqualified deferred compensation plans, supplemental executive retirement plan benefits, cash severance programs, or single-trigger change-in-control benefits. Security costs for Mr. Bezos are considered "reasonable and necessary and for the Company’s benefit."
Shareholder Proposals: The Board typically recommends voting against shareholder proposals that it believes are not in the company's best long-term interests, such as those requesting an extensive climate change report or additional political contribution disclosures, asserting that Amazon already manages these aspects appropriately and transparently.
Share this post