Amazon.com, Inc. - Key Themes and Financial Strategy Briefing
Sources: Amazon Inc. – 2004 Proxy Statement
Amazon Inc. - 2004 Letters to Shareholders
Amazon Inc. - 2004 Annual Report
I. Overarching Financial Philosophy: Free Cash Flow per Share
Amazon.com's core financial objective, consistently emphasized by CEO Jeffrey P. Bezos since its 1997 letter to shareholders, is "free cash flow per share." This metric is prioritized over traditional earnings (net income, EPS, EBITDA) because "shares are worth only the present value of their future cash flows, not the present value of their future earnings." (2004 Shareholder Letter).
Critique of Earnings-Centric Views: Amazon explicitly argues that focusing solely on earnings can be misleading and can even "impair shareholder value in certain circumstances by growing earnings." (2004 Shareholder Letter). This occurs when capital investments required for earnings growth exceed the present value of the cash flow those investments generate.
Hypothetical Example: The 2004 Shareholder Letter illustrates this with a "transportation business" example. Despite 100% compound earnings growth over four years, the business generated a cumulative negative free cash flow of $530 million due to significant capital expenditures for new machines. This highlights that "one cannot assess the creation or destruction of shareholder value with certainty by looking at the income statement alone." (2004 Shareholder Letter).
EBITDA is Insufficient: Similarly, focusing on EBITDA is deemed insufficient because it "isn’t cash flow" and fails to account for crucial capital expenditures necessary to generate that "cash flow" (2004 Shareholder Letter).
II. Drivers of Free Cash Flow
Amazon's strategy to drive free cash flow per share is multifaceted:
Increasing Operating Profit: This is achieved by:
Improving Customer Experience: Continuously focusing on all aspects of the customer experience to drive sales. This includes "increasing selection and lowering prices" (2004 Shareholder Letter).
Maintaining a Lean Cost Structure: This involves "reducing defects in our processes" (2004 Annual Report, Management's Discussion and Analysis).
Efficient Working Capital Management: Amazon boasts a "cash generative operating cycle" (2004 Shareholder Letter) due to its ability to turn inventory quickly. They collect payments from customers before payments are due to suppliers, resulting in a "negative operating cycle that is a source of cash flow." (2004 Annual Report, Management's Discussion and Analysis).
Inventory turnover: 16 in 2004, 18 in 2003, 19 in 2002.
Accounts payable days: 53 in 2004, 50 in 2003, 52 in 2002.
Efficient Capital Expenditures: Amazon emphasizes "modest investments in fixed assets" (2004 Shareholder Letter), which were $246 million at year-end 2004, or 4% of 2004 sales. Capital expenditures, including internal-use software and website development, were $89 million in 2004, $46 million in 2003, and $39 million in 2002.
Managing Share Dilution: The company aims for "efficiently managing share count means more cash flow per share and more long-term value for owners." (2004 Shareholder Letter). Total shares outstanding plus stock-based awards were essentially unchanged from 2003 to 2004 and down 1% over the last three years. They also reduced potential future dilution by repaying over $600 million of convertible debt.
III. Long-Term Business Philosophy and Strategic Pillars
Amazon's consistent philosophy, reiterated from its 1997 shareholder letter, centers on long-term value creation and customer obsession:
Long-Term Focus: "We believe that a fundamental measure of our success will be the shareholder value we create over the long term." (1997 Shareholder Letter). This means making "investment decisions in light of long-term market leadership considerations rather than short-term profitability considerations or short-term Wall Street reactions." (1997 Shareholder Letter).
Customer Obsession: "We will continue to focus relentlessly on our customers." (1997 Shareholder Letter). This is achieved by:
Offering low prices through everyday pricing and free shipping offers.
Providing convenience through continuous innovation in user functionality, fast fulfillment, timely customer service, and a trusted transaction environment (e.g., 1-Click® technology, personalized web pages).
Offering a wide selection of millions of unique products, sold directly by Amazon and by third-party sellers.
Market Leadership and Scale: Amazon believes that "The stronger our market leadership, the more powerful our economic model. Market leadership can translate directly to higher revenue, higher profitability, greater capital velocity, and correspondingly stronger returns on invested capital." (1997 Shareholder Letter). They prioritize growth to achieve scale, believing it is "central to achieving the potential of our business model." (1997 Shareholder Letter).
Data-Driven Decisions and Learning: The company "measure[s] our programs and the effectiveness of our investments analytically, to jettison those that do not provide acceptable returns, and to step up our investment in those that work best. We will continue to learn from both our successes and our failures." (1997 Shareholder Letter).
Bold Investment Decisions: Amazon states it will "make bold rather than timid investment decisions where we see a sufficient probability of gaining market leadership advantages. Some of these investments will pay off, others will not, and we will have learned another valuable lesson in either case." (1997 Shareholder Letter).
Lean Culture: Committed to "spend wisely and maintain our lean culture." (1997 Shareholder Letter).
Talented Employees and Ownership Mindset: Focus on "hiring and retaining versatile and talented employees," and weighting their "compensation to stock options rather than cash," fostering an owner mentality. (1997 Shareholder Letter).
IV. Operational Highlights (2004)
Growth:Consolidated Net Sales grew 31.5% to $6.92 billion in 2004.
International segment revenue grew 53.3% and represented 44.4% of total net sales (up from 38.1% in 2003), with an expectation to reach 50% or more.
Free Cash Flow grew 38% to $477 million in 2004.
Third-Party Sellers: Sales by third-party sellers on Amazon's websites continued to increase, representing 26% of unit sales in 2004 (up from 22% in 2003 and 17% in 2002). These sales generally result in lower revenue but higher gross margin per unit.
Technology Investment: Continued significant investment in technology and content, including the "seller platform; A9.com, our wholly-owned subsidiary focused on search technology... web services; and digital initiatives." (2004 Annual Report, Management's Discussion and Analysis). Capitalized internal-use software development costs were $44 million in 2004.
International Expansion: Acquired Joyo.com in China in September 2004 for $75 million, further expanding international reach.
Shipping Offers: Continued to offer "year-round free shipping offers and lower prices for customers" (2004 Annual Report, Management's Discussion and Analysis), viewing these as an "effective marketing tool." (2004 Annual Report, Management's Discussion and Analysis).
Net Income: Reported net income of $588 million in 2004, but cautioned that this "should not be viewed, on its own, as a material positive event," partly due to a primarily non-cash net tax benefit of $233 million and significant gains/charges from currency exchange rate movements. (2004 Annual Report, Management's Discussion and Analysis).
V. Key Risks and Challenges
Amazon's filings highlight several ongoing risks:
Intense Competition: The e-commerce industry is "rapidly evolving and intensely competitive" with numerous competitors, many having "longer operating histories, larger customer bases, greater brand recognition, and significantly greater financial, marketing, and other resources." (2004 Annual Report, Item 1. Business).
Growth and Expansion Strain: Rapid and significant expansion, both domestically and internationally, "increases the complexity of our business and places a significant strain on our management, operations, technical performance, financial resources, and internal financial control and reporting functions." (2004 Annual Report, Item 1. Business).
New Product/Geographic Risks: Entering new markets means not benefiting from "first-to-market advantage" and potentially lower gross profits. (2004 Annual Report, Item 1. Business).
Fluctuations in Operating Results: Revenue and operating profit growth depend on continued demand, which can be affected by economic conditions, consumer preferences, and world events. Seasonality, particularly the fourth quarter, also places significant strain on operations.
Inventory Risk: Challenges in predicting demand and managing inventory efficiently to avoid overstocking or under-stocking.
Reliance on Shipping Companies: Dependence on a limited number of shipping companies for delivery, posing risks if terms cannot be negotiated or performance problems arise.
Dependence on Third-Party Sellers: Increasing reliance on third parties for fulfillment and the associated risks of product liability and unlawful activities by sellers.
Intellectual Property Protection and Infringement Claims: Difficulty in policing unauthorized use of proprietary rights and ongoing exposure to claims of intellectual property infringement from third parties.
System Interruption: Risk of website unavailability or inefficient order fulfillment due to system interruptions or infrastructure limitations.
Government Regulation: Evolving regulations related to the Internet and e-commerce (e.g., taxation, privacy, content) could harm the business.
Foreign Exchange Risk: Significant exposure to foreign exchange rate fluctuations due to substantial international operations (44% of consolidated revenues in 2004).
Debt Obligations: Significant long-term indebtedness ($1.86 billion at December 31, 2004), requiring substantial future cash flow for interest and principal payments.
VI. Corporate Governance and Executive Compensation
Board Structure: Seven Directors in 2004, with six deemed independent by NASDAQ rules.
Committees: Audit Committee, Leadership Development and Compensation Committee, and Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee, all composed of independent directors.
Audit Committee: Responsible for financial statements, independent auditor oversight, internal audit, and compliance. Tom A. Alberg was designated as the Audit Committee Financial Expert.
Leadership Development and Compensation Committee: Evaluates leadership, sets executive compensation (low base salaries, significant stock awards, some cash bonuses) aiming to align with long-term shareholder value.
Executive Compensation Philosophy:"Base salaries for executive officers in most cases are relatively low, but are accompanied by significant stock award grants and, in certain cases, cash bonuses." (2004 Proxy Statement, Leadership Development and Compensation Committee Report).
CEO Jeffrey P. Bezos received $81,840 in cash compensation in 2003 and has "never received stock-based compensation from the Company" due to his substantial ownership (approx. 26%). (2004 Proxy Statement, Leadership Development and Compensation Committee Report).
In late 2002, the company adopted restricted stock units (RSUs) as its primary vehicle for employee stock-based compensation, moving away from stock options. RSUs are recorded at fair value on the grant date and expensed over the service period. (2004 Annual Report, Management's Discussion and Analysis). Amazon expected stock-based compensation to be $115 million in 2005 due to the early adoption of SFAS 123R.
A shareholder proposal in 2004 requested the Board utilize performance and time-based restricted share programs in lieu of stock options, with specific features like operational performance measures, at least three-year time-based vesting, no dividend/voting rights until vesting, and share retention requirements. The Board recommended against this proposal, arguing that its existing RSU program, which generally vests over three to six years and lacks dividend/voting rights until vested, already aligns employee interests with shareholders.
Share this post